0801討論紀錄

今天的討論主題主要是階層式文獻檢索策略。

老師回應:
我所建構的複雜檢索策略太複雜了，這過程可能會花費過多時間。此時間花費所得的效益有限，因此，可將複雜策略再簡單化一點。

討論結論:
1.找一篇較好的model paper套用即可。
→Interventions for improving the adoption of shared decision making by healthcare professionals

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD006732.pub3/full

Appendix 1. PubMed strategy

[#]	[Search strategies in Pubmed (2 august 2012)]	[Results]
#1	shared decision*[tiab] or sharing decision*[tiab] or informed decision*[tiab] or informed choice*[tiab] or decision aid*[tiab] or ((share*[ti] or sharing*[ti] or informed*[ti]) and (decision*[ti] or deciding*[ti] or choice*[ti])) 中	2118
#2	decision making[mh:noexp] or decision support techniques[mh:noexp] or decision support systems, clinical[mh] or choice behaviour[mh:noexp] or decision making*[tiab] or decision support*[tiab] or choice behaviour*[tiab] or ((decision*[ti] or choice*[ti]) and (making*[ti] or support*[ti] or behaviour*[ti]))	28,283
#3	patient participation[mh] or patient participation*[tiab] or consumer participation*[tiab] or patient involvement*[tiab] or consumer involvement*[tiab] or ((patient*[ti] or consumer*[ti]) and (involvement*[ti] or involving*[ti] or participation*[ti] or participating*[ti]))	3734
#4	professional-patient relations[mh] or ((nurses[mh] or physicians[mh] or nurse*[ti] or physician*[ti] or clinician*[ti] or doctor*[ti] or general practitioner*[ti] or gps[ti] or health care professional*[ti] or healthcare professional*[ti] or health care provider*[ti] or healthcare provider*[ti] or resident*[ti]) and (patients[mh] or patient*[ti] or consumer*[ti] or people*[ti]))	16,592
#5	clinical trial[pt:noexp] or randomized controlled trial[pt] or controlled clinical trial[pt] or evaluation studies[pt] or comparative study[pt] or intervention studies[mh] or Evaluation Studies as Topic[mh:noexp] or program evaluation[mh:noexp] or random allocation[mh] or random*[tiab] or double blind*[tiab] or controlled trial*[tiab] or clinical trial*[tiab] or pretest*[tiab] or pre test*[tiab] or posttest*[tiab] or post test*[tiab] or prepost*[tiab] or pre post*[tiab] or controlled before*[tiab] or "before and after"[tiab] or interrupted time*[tiab] or time serie*[tiab] or intervention*[tiab]	463,581
#6	(#1 OR (#2 AND #3) OR (#2 AND #4) OR (#3 AND #4)) AND #5	1235

 

2.將此model paper的檢索策略1定位在中間程度。

3.將此model paper的檢索策略1,2,3取聯集後與策略5取交集，定位在複雜程度。

4.依照此策略模式進行檢索後，再觀察檢索結果如何。